- Your team is between 25 and 500 employees and you need a centralized HR system, not just payroll.
- You want structured onboarding workflows with task assignments, e-signatures, and pre-boarding communication.
- Performance reviews, goal tracking, and employee engagement surveys are priorities for your HR team.
- You already have a payroll solution or are willing to pay extra for BambooHR's payroll add-on to keep everything in one system.
- You run a small business under 100 employees and payroll accuracy is your top concern.
- You want transparent, published pricing without needing to sit through a sales call for a quote.
- You need to pay international contractors or are considering EOR services for global hiring.
- Your HR needs are straightforward and you prefer a tool that handles payroll, taxes, and benefits in one clean workflow.
Gusto keeps things simple with published pricing across three tiers. The Simple plan runs $49/month plus $6 per employee, the Plus plan is $80/month plus $12 per employee, and Premium costs $180/month plus $22 per employee. As of March 2026, the Simple plan base went up from $40 to $49. A contractor-only plan is also available at $35/month plus $6 per person, with the base fee waived for the first six months.
BambooHR does not publish pricing. You have to request a quote, which makes direct comparison harder. Based on publicly reported figures, the Core plan starts around $10 per employee per month, Pro runs about $17, and Elite is roughly $25. Companies with 25 or fewer employees pay a flat rate starting at $250/month regardless of headcount. There is also a one-time implementation fee, typically 5 to 15 percent of annual software costs. Payroll is an add-on module with its own per-employee charge on top of the base HRIS price.
For a 50-person company, Gusto Simple would cost around $349/month. BambooHR Core would be roughly $500/month before the payroll add-on. Once you add payroll to BambooHR, the total often exceeds Gusto unless you specifically need the deeper HR feature set.
Payroll is where Gusto pulls ahead. It handles multi-state tax filing, automatic tax payments, W-2 and 1099 generation, and next-day direct deposit on higher plans. BambooHR added payroll through a built-in module, but users consistently report it feels less polished. BambooHR payroll only covers US employees and lacks some of the automation Gusto has refined over years of being a payroll-first product.
On the HR side, BambooHR is clearly stronger. Its employee database is well-organized with custom fields, document storage, and a clean org chart. The onboarding module lets you build task lists, send pre-boarding packets, and collect e-signatures before day one. Performance management includes goal tracking, peer feedback, and scheduled review cycles. Gusto offers basic onboarding checklists and document signing, but nothing close to BambooHR's depth.
Benefits administration is a draw with different strengths. Gusto acts as a licensed broker in most states, so you can shop for health plans, set up 401(k)s, and manage HSAs directly in the platform. BambooHR connects to third-party brokers and handles enrollment, but you still need an outside benefits relationship.
Time tracking is available in both, though neither is best-in-class. Gusto includes it on Plus and Premium plans. BambooHR offers it as a paid add-on. Both integrate with dedicated time tracking tools if you need more.
Final Take
This is not a case where one tool is better than the other across the board. BambooHR and Gusto serve different primary needs, and the right pick depends on what keeps you up at night. If your biggest pain point is running payroll, managing tax filings, and handling benefits for a small US team, Gusto is the better fit. It's simpler, cheaper for most small businesses, and does payroll really well. If your team is growing and you need a proper HR system with onboarding, performance management, and employee data at the center, BambooHR is worth the higher price. Just know that you'll pay extra for payroll on top of the HRIS, and the payroll experience won't match what Gusto offers. Most companies under 50 employees are better off starting with Gusto. Once you pass 50 to 100 employees and HR complexity ramps up, BambooHR starts to make more sense.
Gusto vs Rippling
Gusto or Rippling? Pick Gusto if you need simple payroll for a small US team. Pick Rippling if you're scaling fast and need unified HR and IT.
BambooHR vs Rippling
BambooHR or Rippling? Pick BambooHR if you want simple HRIS for small US teams. Pick Rippling if you need all-in-one HR, payroll, and IT.
Gusto vs ADP
Gusto or ADP? Pick the right payroll platform with a pricing breakdown, feature comparison, and real user ratings from 12,000+ G2 reviews.